Coase Colored Glasses

Tuesday, April 05, 2005

Will New "Green" Buildings Make A Difference?

A bill in Washington state that would require higher environmental standards of all new public buildings recently passed in the state legislature and is awaiting the signature of Governor Christine Gregoire. See the story here. The buildings would be required to be more energy efficient, and conserve more water. Would the benefits of such legislation out weigh the costs though? There is a division over that issue even though the bill has passed. The oppostion argues that there is not a compelling public interest for the bill and that it's just another misallocation of tax payer money. The proponents argue though with backing from the Green Builidng Council in Washington D.C. that such "green" buildings actually enhance worker performance and in the case of public schools produce higher test scores than other "non-green" schools. I haven't been able to find any real hard data on the subject but I think it's interesting.

2 Comments:

At 8:52 AM, Anonymous Anonymous said...

The good and bad news is that there's a grandfather clause. It could cost more to build new buildings and be certain that they're up to the official standard than it would to renovate old buildings. It doesn't require them to replace their current public buildings (that would be absurdly costly), but it also means that they have more incentive to do things like force overcrowding in schools rather than building new ones.

(I'm going to ignore the overcrowding debate for now, but in case you were wondering, I support reducing teachers' workloads.)

 
At 10:42 AM, Blogger Nicole and Andy said...

I think that this could be similar to the smokestack scrubbers we talked about earlier this year. There really is little incentive to build new buildings, rather I feel many would choose to overcrowd.
I would also love to see the actual tests that they did to prove that kids at green schools did better. In my mind, I can see that more from a monetary standpoint. Only those with money would have the green schools which normally have higher test scores anyway, ranging from better teachers, to better materials, to family expectations. I don't know how much I believe that the idea is currently plausable for the nation on the facts produced, but it has potential.

 

Post a Comment

<< Home